Unaged Luxury
VaultShop

Royal Oak vs Nautilus: Which Luxury Steel Sports Watch Should You Buy

Audemars Piguet Royal Oak vs Patek Philippe Nautilus: design, current prices from our record, and which icon suits which buyer.

The Royal Oak and the Nautilus share an architect and an era, and buyers constantly weigh one against the other. This article looks at the choice itself, as a buyer decision. For the individual watches, see our companion articles on the Nautilus 5711 versus 5726 and the Daytona versus the Royal Oak.

The short verdict

Buy the Royal Oak if you want the more accessible and more varied of the two: more references, more sizes, and a market where a steel watch is attainable. Buy the Nautilus if you want the rarer object and accept that steel Nautilus pricing has moved far beyond what the watch costs at the counter.

Shared DNA, different personalities

Audemars Piguet launched the Royal Oak in April 1972, and Patek Philippe presented the Nautilus in 1976. Gérald Genta designed both, and both turned a steel sports watch into a luxury object.

The Royal Oak is defined by its octagonal bezel and exposed screws. Genta drew the Nautilus with the portholes of ships in mind, and its case has a softer, rounded outline. The Royal Oak is the more angular and graphic of the two. The Nautilus is the softer, more flowing design.

What each costs today

All figures are Unaged Luxury estimates for November 2026, full set.

WatchOur estimateNotes
Royal Oak 15500ST (41 mm, Black dial)$45,000US list $31,900
Royal Oak 15510ST (41 mm, Black dial)$49,000US list $31,900
Royal Oak 15202ST Jumbo (Blue dial)$75,000US list $40,100, 39 mm
Nautilus 5726/1A (40.5 mm, Blue dial)$147,500annual calendar, US list $62,766
Nautilus 5711/1A (Blue dial)$155,000discontinued in 2021

For a like for like steel time and date watch, the Royal Oak 15500ST or 15510ST sits near $45,000 to $49,000. The Nautilus 5711/1A is $155,000. That is more than three times the price for the same category of watch, and it is the single most important fact in this comparison.

Why the Nautilus is so far ahead

Patek Philippe discontinued the steel Nautilus 5711/1A in 2021, so every example now comes from the secondary market. Our figure for the Blue dial is $155,000, White is $147,500 and Green is $285,000. Even the current 5726/1A trades at 2.35 times its US list in our record. The Royal Oak has a deeper bench of references, so a buyer can enter with a more modest figure.

Which one for which buyer

  • You want the best steel sports watch under a sensible budget: Royal Oak 15500ST or 15510ST.
  • You want the Jumbo: the 39 mm 15202ST, which trades at 1.87 times its US list in our record.
  • You want an annual calendar with a Nautilus case: the 5726/1A at $147,500.
  • You want the rarest steel icon in the category: Nautilus 5711/1A.
  • You prefer a graphic, angular design: Royal Oak.
  • You prefer a flowing, softer one: Nautilus.

Dial color moves the price

On the Royal Oak 15510ST, our record shows Blue at $61,000, Green at $55,000 and Black at $49,000. On the Nautilus 5726/1A, Blue at $147,500 sits $25,000 above Grey at $122,500. For help reading these references, see our Royal Oak guide to the 15500ST, 15510ST, 15202ST and 16202ST and the Nautilus secondary market guide.

What we tell buyers who are torn

If you are choosing purely on enjoyment, go to the watch you cannot stop thinking about. If you are choosing on price, the Royal Oak wins easily. If you are choosing on rarity, the Nautilus wins. One sensible path is to buy the Royal Oak first, live with it for a year, and decide later whether the Nautilus is worth a far larger commitment. Because the figures above are for full sets, remember that a watch without its box and papers will be priced differently. See full set versus papers versus watch only.

Sources


Figures are Unaged Luxury estimates as of November 21, 2026: retail-equivalent, full set unless stated. Estimates, not offers. Reference numbers in the text link to their live value pages, which move with the market.

Common questions

Which is a better investment, Royal Oak or Nautilus?

We do not give investment advice. In our November 2026 record the steel Nautilus 5711/1A is $155,000 and the Royal Oak 15510ST in Black is $49,000, so the entry points are very different.

Who designed the Royal Oak and the Nautilus?

Gérald Genta designed both: the Royal Oak, launched by Audemars Piguet in 1972, and the Nautilus, presented by Patek Philippe in 1976.

Is the Nautilus 5711 still made?

No. Patek Philippe discontinued the steel 5711/1A in 2021, which is a large part of why it is priced where it is.

Can you find a Royal Oak or Nautilus for me?

Yes. Send us the reference and we source it, verified and shipped insured anywhere in the US.

Referenced in this guide

Value any watch
  1. Audemars Piguet Royal Oak 15500STBlack dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2021, full set$45,000
  2. Patek Philippe Nautilus 5726/1ABlue dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2023, full set$147,500
  3. Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711/1ABlue dial (most quoted dial), any year, full set$155,000

Estimates as of November 21, 2026. Not offers. Retail-equivalent. Each value page carries today's figure.

Looking for one?

Send us the reference and we source it, verified and shipped insured anywhere in the US.

Related in the Journal

More on Audemars Piguet
  1. Market data, November 21, 2026

    Patek Philippe Nautilus After the 5711: Prices Since the Steel Reference Ended

    Patek ended the steel 5711/1A in 2021. Our value pages now price the blue at $155,000, the 5726/1A at 2.35x list and the 7118/1A up 53% since 2021.

  2. Market data, November 21, 2026

    Discontinued References vs Their Successors: What the Old Watch Costs Next to the New One

    Six Rolex and Audemars Piguet pairs, old reference against new, priced from our value pages. The successor is 12% to 27% higher in every pair.

  3. Market data, November 21, 2026

    The 2022 Watch Market Peak and What Came After: The Index 2020 to 2026

    The Unaged Luxury Watch Index peaked at 143.2 in 2022, fell to 114.9 by 2025 and reads 121.2 in 2026. What fell, what held, and how to use it.

Ask Unaged

A question about this watch, its history or the market? Ask it here. We answer personally, and the best questions are published on Ask Unaged.

Your question may be published without your contact details. We use your email or phone only to reply to you. Privacy.