Discontinued References vs Their Successors: What the Old Watch Costs Next to the New One
Six Rolex and Audemars Piguet pairs, old reference against new, priced from our value pages. The successor is 12% to 27% higher in every pair.

When a maker replaces a reference, buyers ask the same question: is the old one cheaper? We took six matched pairs from Rolex and Audemars Piguet, and set our current estimates side by side. In every pair the newer watch is the dearer one. Two further comparisons, the Hulk and the Nautilus, do not fit the pattern and we explain why.
The pairs
All figures are our current full-set estimates for the dial named, from the public value pages.
| Old reference | Estimate | New reference | Estimate | New against old |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Daytona 116500LN, white | $34,000 | Daytona 126500LN, white | $38,500 | +13% |
| Submariner 116610, black | $12,500 | Submariner 126610, black | $14,000 | +12% |
| GMT-Master II 116710, Batman | $16,250 | GMT-Master II 126710, Batman | $18,750 | +15% |
| Submariner 116613, Bluesy | $15,250 | Submariner 126613, Bluesy | $17,750 | +16% |
| Royal Oak 15400ST, black | $40,000 | Royal Oak 15500ST, black | $45,000 | +13% |
| Royal Oak Jumbo 15202ST, blue | $75,000 | Royal Oak Jumbo 16202ST, blue | $95,000 | +27% |
All six sit between 12% and 27% above the reference they replaced. The median is +14%.
Why the newer one costs more
Our reading is that two things are at work. The first is specification: each newer reference carries a newer calibre, and the newer watch is the one still in the maker's catalogue. The second is the cycle. The older references went through some of the sharpest moves we noted in which brand fell furthest after 2022: the 15400ST fell 39.3% from its 2022 point and the 116610 fell 25.9%. The market has priced the older references down more than the newer ones.
The facts behind each switch
- Submariner: Monochrome reported that Rolex's 2020 collection of the 41 mm Submariner Date, references 126610LN, 126610LV, 126613 and 126618, replaced the 40 mm 116610 line, moving to calibre 3235.
- GMT-Master II: the 126710BLNR arrived at Baselworld 2019 with a Jubilee bracelet and the calibre 3285.
- Daytona: the 116500LN was introduced at Baselworld in 2016 and replaced in March 2023 by the 126500LN, which moved to calibre 4131.
- Royal Oak: the 15500ST replaced the 15400ST in 2019 with calibre 4302; Hodinkee reported the 16202 as the first new Jumbo reference in 22 years, replacing the 15202.
The two exceptions
The Hulk breaks the pattern. The 116610 in the Hulk (LV) version, green dial and green bezel, is estimated at $21,000. Monochrome describes the current 126610LV as the Hulk's successor, but it has a black dial with the green bezel; our value page lists it as the Starbucks, and our estimate is $15,250. The successor is 27.4% below the old one. Our reading is that this is a dial effect, not a reference effect: the green dial was not carried into the new reference, and the market prices the Hulk for that design.
The Nautilus is not a pair either. Patek's 5811/1G replaced the 5711, but it is white gold, not steel. Our blue estimates are $155,000 for the 5711/1A and $215,000 for the 5811/1G, 38.7% higher, against a list of $82,021 for the 5811/1G. Metal and price class changed, so the pair is a market comparison only.
What to take from it
- A discontinued reference is not automatically a bargain. In every like-for-like pair above, the replaced watch is cheaper, and by a double-digit percentage. That is the price of buying the old specification, and some buyers prefer it.
- Buy the old one for the design, the new one for the movement. The newer references carry the newer calibres, which is a real reason to pay the difference.
- Watch for signature designs. If the old reference has a signature feature that was not carried forward, as the Hulk's green dial was not, expect the market to price that feature itself.
Read next: the steel Royal Oak by reference and what the set does to the price.
Figures are Unaged Luxury estimates, November 2026. Percentages are calculated from the published estimates. Estimates, not offers.
Sources
- monochrome-watches.com/2020-rolex-submariner-date-41mm-126610lv-kermit-126610ln-price/
- bobswatches.com/rolex-blog/new-releases/2019-rolex-batman-gmt-master-jubilee.html
- alanfurman.com/rolex-daytona-116500ln-vs-126500ln/
- hodinkee.com/articles/royal-oak-selfwinding-41mm-ref-15500-introducing
- hodinkee.com/articles/the-audemars-piguet-royal-oak-reference-16202-jumbo
- hodinkee.com/articles/a-collectors-guide-to-the-patek-philippe-nautilus-5711
Figures are Unaged Luxury estimates as of November 21, 2026: retail-equivalent, full set unless stated. Estimates, not offers. Reference numbers in the text link to their live value pages, which move with the market.
Common questions
Are discontinued Rolex watches cheaper than the current ones?
In the like-for-like pairs we priced, yes: the 116610 black is $12,500 against $14,000 for the 126610 black, and the 116500LN white is $34,000 against $38,500 for the 126500LN white.
Is the Rolex Hulk worth more than the current Submariner?
Our estimate for the 116610 Hulk is $21,000, against $15,250 for the 126610LV with a green bezel and black dial.
How much more is the Royal Oak Jumbo 16202ST than the 15202ST?
Our estimate for the blue 16202ST is $95,000 against $75,000 for the blue 15202ST, 26.7% higher, with the same US list price of $40,100.
Did the Patek Nautilus 5811/1G replace the steel 5711?
Hodinkee reports the 5811/1G in white gold as the 5711's replacement. It is a different metal and price class, so it is not a like-for-like pair.
Referenced in this guide
Value any watch- Rolex Cosmograph Daytona 126500LNWhite dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2023 to 2025, full set$38,500
- Rolex Cosmograph Daytona 116500LNWhite dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2021 to 2024, full set$34,000
- Rolex Submariner 126610Black (most quoted variation), most quoted card years 2020 to 2022, full set$14,000
- Rolex Submariner 116610Hulk (LV) (most quoted variation), most quoted card years 2016 to 2018, full set$21,000
- Rolex GMT-Master II 126710Batman (BLNR) (most quoted variation), most quoted card years 2017 to 2024, full set$18,750
- Rolex GMT-Master II 116710Black (most quoted variation), most quoted card years 2011 to 2016, full set$13,000
- Audemars Piguet Royal Oak 15500STBlack dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2021, full set$45,000
- Audemars Piguet Royal Oak 15400STBlack dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2016 to 2017, full set$40,000
- Audemars Piguet Royal Oak 16202STBlue dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2022 to 2023, full set$95,000
- Audemars Piguet Royal Oak 15202STBlue dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2013 to 2014, full set$75,000
- Rolex Submariner 126613Bluesy (LB) (most quoted variation), most quoted card years 2020 to 2024, full set$17,750
- Rolex Submariner 116613Black (most quoted variation), most quoted card years 2016 to 2019, full set$14,000
- Patek Philippe Nautilus 5811/1GBlue dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2023 to 2024, full set$215,000
- Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711/1ABlue dial (most quoted dial), any year, full set$155,000
Estimates as of November 21, 2026. Not offers. Retail-equivalent. Each value page carries today's figure.
Looking for one?
Send us the reference and we source it, verified and shipped insured anywhere in the US.
Related in the Journal
The Journal
Rolex Steel Sports Watches Since 2022: Which Held Value Best and Worst
Submariner, Daytona and GMT value history from our public pages: the 116500LN lost 18.7% since 2021, the 126610 5.4%, and the 126500LN is rising.

Which Brand Fell Furthest After the 2022 Peak: Audemars Piguet, Rolex or Patek Philippe?
Steel Royal Oaks lost about 40% from 2022 to 2026, Rolex sports watches about 18%, Patek about 14%. The reference-level points behind the numbers.

Royal Oak 15400, 15500 and 15510: How Each Reference Change Moved the Price
The 15400ST gave way to the 15500ST in 2019 and the 15510ST in 2022. What the steel Royal Oak and the Jumbo 15202 to 16202 switch did to value pages.

