Unaged Luxury
VaultShop

Tudor Black Bay 58 vs Rolex Submariner: How They Compare

Tudor Black Bay 58 against the Rolex Submariner 124060 and 126610: size, depth, movement, shared history and our Submariner figures.

The Tudor Black Bay 58 and the Rolex Submariner are cousins. Tudor was created by Hans Wilsdorf, the founder of Rolex, and the Tudor name was registered in 1926. Both make a steel dive watch with a rotating bezel. They are different watches at very different price points. This guide sets out what is the same, what is not, and where our figures apply.

A note on figures

Our value pages do not yet price the black Black Bay 58 in this table. The burgundy Black Bay 58, 7939A1A0RU, is $3,400 full set in our November 2026 record, on limited data, against a US list of $4,975 to $5,350 on tudorwatch.com, October 2026, so it sits below its list. We give you the Submariner figures from the same record and compare the two watches on their specifications.

The short verdict

If you want a steel dive watch in a smaller 39 mm case, the Black Bay 58 is a good choice. If you want a Rolex, with the Submariner's 300 metres of water resistance, buy the Submariner. They answer different questions.

The specifications

Tudor Black Bay 58Rolex Submariner 124060Rolex Submariner 126610
Case39 mm steel41 mm Oystersteel41 mm Oystersteel
Water resistance200 m300 m300 m
MovementManufacture calibre MT5400-UCalibre 3230Calibre 3235
Power reserve65 hoursAbout 70 hoursAbout 70 hours
DateNoNoYes

The Black Bay 58 takes its name from the reference 7924 of 1958, the first Tudor dive watch waterproof to 200 metres. The Submariner was introduced in 1953.

Size on the wrist

The Black Bay 58 is two millimeters smaller across the case than the 41 mm Submariner. On a smaller wrist, that matters. The Submariner's 41 mm is the size Rolex moved to in 2020, up from 40 mm.

Our Submariner figures

Unaged Luxury estimates, November 2026, full set.

WatchVariationOur estimateMost quoted card years
Submariner 124060Black$13,2502022 to 2024
Submariner 126610Black$14,0002020 to 2022
Submariner 126610Starbucks (LV)$15,2502020 to 2022

The maker's US list prices on rolex.com in October 2026 are $10,050 for the 124060 and $11,350 for the 126610 black. The value pages show the market at 1.32x and 1.23x of those lists.

Which one for which buyer

  • A 39 mm case and a vintage inspired look: Black Bay 58.
  • 300 metres and the Rolex name: Submariner.
  • A watch priced above its maker's list in our record: the Submariner, at 1.23x to 1.32x on its value pages, where the burgundy Black Bay 58 sits below its list.
  • A date window: Submariner 126610.

Tudor also makes a GMT. For that comparison, read Rolex GMT-Master II versus Tudor Black Bay GMT. For the Submariner itself, see our Submariner buying guide and the 124060 and 126610 guides.

Choosing between them

Start with the wrist. A 39 mm case and a 41 mm case differ by only two millimeters, but on a smaller wrist that is noticeable. Then decide on depth rating and the name on the dial.

What the figures show is where the Submariner stands in the market: the black 124060 is $13,250 in our November 2026 record and the black 126610 is $14,000. That is a market number for a full set, which includes the box and papers. Our explainer on full set versus watch only shows what that means for your price.

If you want the Submariner

Tell us the reference and the set you want. We source it, verified, and ship it insured anywhere in the US.

Sources


Figures are Unaged Luxury estimates as of November 21, 2026: retail-equivalent, full set unless stated. Estimates, not offers. Reference numbers in the text link to their live value pages, which move with the market.

Common questions

Is Tudor made by Rolex?

Tudor was created by Hans Wilsdorf, the founder of Rolex, and the Tudor name was registered in 1926. The two brands make different watches.

How big is the Black Bay 58?

Tudor lists the steel Black Bay 58 at 39 mm, with 200 metres of water resistance.

How much is a Submariner 124060?

Our estimate, full set, November 2026, is $13,250.

Does the Black Bay 58 have a date?

No. The Black Bay 58 is a time only dive watch. The Submariner with a date is the 126610.

Referenced in this guide

Value any watch
  1. Rolex Submariner 124060Black dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2022 to 2024, full set$13,250
  2. Rolex Submariner 126610Black (most quoted variation), most quoted card years 2020 to 2022, full set$14,000

Estimates as of November 21, 2026. Not offers. Retail-equivalent. Each value page carries today's figure.

Looking for one?

Send us the reference and we source it, verified and shipped insured anywhere in the US.

Related in the Journal

More on Rolex
  1. Comparisons, November 21, 2026

    Rolex Submariner Date vs No Date: 126610 vs 124060

    Submariner 126610 with date against the 124060 no date: size, movement, our November 2026 estimates and which one suits you.

  2. Market data, November 21, 2026

    Rolex Submariner 126610 Price History: 2020 to 2026

    The 126610LN is $14,000 on our value page, 1.23x the US list. Annual points $14,800 (2020), $16,600 (2021), $14,600 (2025), $15,700 (2026).

  3. Market data, November 21, 2026

    Rolex Steel Sports Watches Since 2022: Which Held Value Best and Worst

    Submariner, Daytona and GMT value history from our public pages: the 116500LN lost 18.7% since 2021, the 126610 5.4%, and the 126500LN is rising.

Ask Unaged

A question about this watch, its history or the market? Ask it here. We answer personally, and the best questions are published on Ask Unaged.

Your question may be published without your contact details. We use your email or phone only to reply to you. Privacy.