Unaged Luxury
VaultShop

Rolex Explorer vs Explorer II: Which One Should You Buy

Explorer 124270 and 224270 against the Explorer II 226570: size, function, current prices and a verdict for each type of buyer.

The Explorer and the Explorer II look alike across a room and are very different watches on the wrist. One is a stripped back, three hand classic. The other adds a 24 hour hand and a bolder case. Choosing between them is mostly about size, function and how much you want to spend.

The short verdict

Buy the Explorer if you want the purest and most versatile Rolex tool watch, and the choice of 36 or 40 mm. Buy the Explorer II if you want a larger, more visible watch with a 24 hour hand and you like a sportier presence. For most people the Explorer is the better everyday watch and the Explorer II is the better statement.

Two histories

Rolex introduced the Explorer in 1953, following the first ascent of Everest, and the watch has stayed true to its simple, legible formula ever since. The Explorer II arrived in 1971, with an engraved 24 hour bezel and an additional 24 hour hand that Rolex designed for speleologists and polar expeditions, who need to tell daytime from night time hours.

Our three references:

  • Explorer 124270: 36 mm Oystersteel, Black dial.
  • Explorer 224270: 40 mm Oystersteel, Black dial.
  • Explorer II 226570: 42 mm Oystersteel, in White or Black.

What each costs

Unaged Luxury estimates, November 2026, full set.

WatchSizeOur estimateUS listMarket against list
Explorer 12427036 mm$8,900$7,9001.13x
Explorer 22427040 mm$9,300$8,3501.11x
Explorer II 22657042 mm$11,750$10,600n/a

The Explorer 36 trades about 13 percent over its list price and the 40 mm about 11 percent. The 40 mm version is $400 more. The Explorer II is $11,750, $2,850 above the 36 mm Explorer and $2,450 above the 40 mm. Our 40 mm figure rests on limited data, so treat it as a guide.

How they differ in daily use

The Explorer is a simple three hand watch with a 3, 6 and 9 dial. It is easy to read at a glance and light on the wrist. The Explorer II has a fixed steel bezel with a 24 hour scale, a dedicated 24 hour hand and a bigger case. The 24 hour hand can follow a second time zone, but with a fixed bezel it reads only one extra zone, where the GMT-Master II's rotatable bezel adds flexibility.

If you travel and want a second time zone with a rotating bezel, our GMT-Master II complete guide is the better route.

Which one for which buyer

  • A first Rolex that goes with everything: Explorer 124270, 36 mm.
  • You want an Explorer with a more modern size: 224270, 40 mm.
  • Large wrist, wants presence: Explorer II 226570.
  • Wants a second time zone, a casual one: Explorer II.
  • Smaller wrist: 36 mm Explorer.
  • Smallest spend of these three: Explorer 124270, at $8,900.

What to look for

The Explorer's appeal is in its dial legibility and its simplicity. When we source one for a client we confirm the dial printing, the case and the set. A complete set, with its card, is worth more. Our guide to full set versus papers versus watch only explains how the paperwork shifts the price. For another Rolex of similar price, see the first luxury watch buying guide.

The Explorer sizes in plain terms

Rolex now offers the Explorer in two sizes, 36 mm and 40 mm, and both are in our record. The 36 matches the diameter of the original 1953 model, a size Rolex brought back in 2021, and sits at $8,900 in our record. The 40 at $9,300 is for buyers who find 36 mm small. The difference is only $400, so choose on how it sits on your wrist. If you can, try both. A few millimeters changes the way the dial reads.

Sources


Figures are Unaged Luxury estimates as of November 21, 2026: retail-equivalent, full set unless stated. Estimates, not offers. Reference numbers in the text link to their live value pages, which move with the market.

Common questions

What is the difference between the Explorer and the Explorer II?

The Explorer is a three hand watch. The Explorer II adds a 24 hour hand and a fixed 24 hour bezel in a larger 42 mm case.

How much is a Rolex Explorer 124270?

Our November 2026 estimate for the Black dial, full set, is $8,900.

How much is an Explorer II 226570?

Our estimate, full set, is $11,750.

Which Explorer size is best?

The 36 mm suits smaller wrists and is the classic. The 40 mm is the modern size, and the Explorer II is 42 mm.

Referenced in this guide

Value any watch
  1. Rolex Explorer 124270Black dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2022 to 2023, full set$8,900
  2. Rolex Explorer 224270Black dial (most quoted dial), most quoted card years 2023 to 2025, full set$9,300
  3. Rolex Explorer II 226570most quoted card years 2023 to 2025, full set$11,750

Estimates as of November 21, 2026. Not offers. Retail-equivalent. Each value page carries today's figure.

Looking for one?

Send us the reference and we source it, verified and shipped insured anywhere in the US.

Related in the Journal

More on Rolex
  1. Comparisons, November 21, 2026

    Rolex vs Omega: Which Brand Should You Buy

    Rolex against Omega overall: history, resale behavior against list price, and which brand fits which buyer, with figures from our November 2026 record.

  2. Reference guides, November 21, 2026

    Rolex Explorer 36 124270: Steel 36 mm Guide and Value

    The Rolex Explorer 36 ref. 124270: the smaller steel Explorer, calibre 3230, our November 2026 estimate and the premium over list, full set.

  3. Reference guides, November 21, 2026

    Rolex Explorer 40 224270: Steel 40 mm Guide and Value

    The Rolex Explorer 40 ref. 224270: calibre 3230, one black dial, our November 2026 estimate, retail comparison and how to buy one full set.

Ask Unaged

A question about this watch, its history or the market? Ask it here. We answer personally, and the best questions are published on Ask Unaged.

Your question may be published without your contact details. We use your email or phone only to reply to you. Privacy.